July 30, 2013
Authored by: Kathy Sherby, Linsey Glosier and Larry Brody
Taxpayers/insureds are often surprised when they are taxed on the value of an old policy that was underwater, when it was transferred to them, causing them to assume that the policy had no value for the government to tax. Here again, the taxpayers in Schwab v. Commissioner (9th Cir. 2013), were surprised that they had recognized taxable income on the distribution to them of life insurance policies from their non-qualified plan, which had surrender charges that exceed their cash value.
Michael and Kathryn, a married couple, were employees of Angels and Cowboys, Inc., which sponsored a non-qualified multi-employer welfare benefit plan that was administered by a third party. Each of them caused the plan to purchase, with a single premium, a variable universal life insurance policy with a three-year no lapse guarantee.